Can a Florida DUI be reduced to reckless driving?

"Can it be reduced?" is one of the first questions after a DUI arrest. In Florida the usual lesser charge people mean is reckless driving under section 316.192, Florida Statutes. This page explains the statutory limits on pleading a DUI down, how the two charges compare, and the published Palm Beach County program that ends in a reckless driving plea for some first-time drivers. It cannot predict any one case. For how Mr. Mead approaches the DUI charge itself, see the main DUI defense page.

How does a DUI become a reckless driving case, step by step?

1. Check the statutory limits. Was a breath or blood test 0.15 or more? Was there a crash with damage, injury or death? If so, section 316.656(2) bars a judge from accepting a plea to a lesser offense.
2. Review the evidence. The defense gets the reports, videos and test records and looks at the stop, the arrest and the testing.
3. Talk with the State Attorney. Any reduced charge is the prosecutor's offer, not an application the driver files. In Palm Beach County, the first-time program has its own early timing rules.
4. Amend or dismiss the DUI count. The State either files a reckless driving charge or, in the Palm Beach program, issues a nolle prosequi on the DUI after the plea.
5. Enter the plea. The judge decides whether to accept it and whether to withhold adjudication, which section 316.656 does not bar for reckless driving.
6. Serve the sentence. Probation, DUI school where alcohol contributed, and the program's conditions follow.

What does Florida law say about pleading a DUI down?

Section 316.656 sets three limits. The first is about the test result:

"No trial judge may accept a plea of guilty to a lesser offense from a person charged under the provisions of this act who has been given a breath or blood test to determine blood or breath alcohol content, the results of which show a blood or breath alcohol content by weight of 0.15 percent or more."Florida Statutes s. 316.656(2)(a)

The second covers crash cases: no trial judge may accept a plea of guilty to a lesser offense from a person charged under section 316.193(3), the DUI subsection for crashes causing damage to property or person, serious bodily injury or death, or charged with manslaughter resulting from the operation of a motor vehicle or with vehicular homicide (s. 316.656(2)(b)). The third is that no court may "suspend, defer, or withhold adjudication of guilt or imposition of sentence" for a DUI (s. 316.656(1)). So a DUI that ends in a DUI conviction is always a conviction. FLHSMV's summary of the law repeats the point: courts may not withhold adjudication in DUI cases or reduce a DUI charge if the alcohol level was 0.15 or greater.

How does reckless driving compare with a DUI?

Reckless driving is driving "in willful or wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property" (s. 316.192(1)(a)). It is still a criminal charge, but the statute sets lighter limits and fewer automatic consequences. The insurance requirement that follows a DUI conviction is explained in FR-44 insurance after a Florida DUI.

The DUI numbers above are for a first conviction; the full table for every conviction level is on our page about Florida DUI penalties. Reckless driving that causes damage to property or person is a first-degree misdemeanor, and reckless driving that causes serious bodily injury is a third-degree felony (s. 316.192(3)).

When can a reckless driving resolution be on the table?

The statute settles the first questions: what the test showed and whether there was a crash. Beyond those limits, a reduced charge is not something a driver can apply for. The State Attorney decides what to offer, and the judge decides whether to accept a plea. What usually shapes that conversation is the strength of the evidence: whether the stop and arrest were lawful, how the field exercises and the breath or blood test were given and recorded, and what the video shows. A careful review of those questions is where a defense starts, whatever the final result.

What does the Palm Beach County first-time program offer?

The Palm Beach County State Attorney publishes a "1st Time D.U.I. Offender Program." Its terms say a driver approved by the office's D.U.I. filing division "will be required to perform four pre-conditions (and stay “crime-free”) within a two-month time frame in order to obtain a State-approved plea to Reckless Driving." If all pre-conditions are completed on time, the program sheet lists the resolution the State will offer, including:

• "Plea of guilty to Reckless Driving (adjudication will be withheld)"
• "State of Florida will issue a nolle prosequi on the D.U.I. charge"
• "Probation for a 12-month period, with conditions based on “Tier” level assigned"

The sheet adds: "Upon successful completion of probation, you will not receive any points against your license." Its eligibility list excludes, among others, "cases involving Defendant breath samples over the 0.200 B.A.C. mark" and "cases involving accidents," and it says that "A defendant's eligibility is determined at the sole discretion of the D.U.I. filing unit and may be based on relevant factors not mentioned above." The program's tiers include readings between 0.150 and 0.200, while section 316.656(2)(a), quoted above, limits pleas to a lesser offense at 0.15 or more; the program resolves the DUI count through a nolle prosequi, which is the State's own decision. Whether any of this fits a particular case is a question for your lawyer, and nothing here promises admission or a result. The full tiers, timing rules and exclusions are on our page about the Palm Beach County first-time DUI program.

In Broward County, the State Attorney's published list of diversion programs does not include a DUI-specific program. The programs both counties do publish are summarized on our page about pretrial diversion in Palm Beach and Broward.

Does a reckless driving plea stay on my record?

A reckless driving plea is still a criminal case on the record. What it means later, for example for sealing, can depend on whether adjudication was withheld, which we explain on our page about withhold of adjudication in Florida. When alcohol contributed, the court must also send the person to a DUI program course and evaluation, and if the person does not complete the course or a referred treatment, FLHSMV cancels the driving privilege until it is done (s. 316.192(5)). Whether that record can later be sealed is covered in can a DUI be sealed or expunged in Florida.

What changes the answer?

• The test result. At 0.15 or more, a judge may not accept a plea to a lesser offense (s. 316.656(2)(a)). How breath results are produced is covered on our page about Florida's breath test rules.
• A crash. Any DUI charged under section 316.193(3), for damage, injury or death, falls under the bar in section 316.656(2)(b); see what happens when a DUI involves a crash.
• A refusal. With no test result, the 0.15 limit does not apply, but a refusal count may be added; the Palm Beach program's Tier 3 addresses first refusals.
• Prior record. The Palm Beach program excludes prior similar offenses, prior formal diversion and prior prison sentences, among other things.
• Timing. The Palm Beach program's plea must be entered at arraignment, before any defense motions, discovery demands or jury trial demands.
• Other driving charges. Racing and stunt driving are separate offenses with their own consequences, described on our street racing page. Reckless driving itself is one of the criminal traffic charges covered on our criminal traffic citations page.

A worked example

For example, take a hypothetical first-time driver arrested in Boca Raton with a breath result of 0.12, no crash, no passengers and a valid license. Nothing in section 316.656(2) stops a reduced plea at that level. If the Palm Beach State Attorney's DUI filing unit approves the driver for its first-time program, the driver has two months to complete 20 community service hours, DUI school, the Victim Impact Panel and interlock installation. At the next court date, the State would offer a plea to reckless driving with adjudication withheld and a nolle prosequi on the DUI, with 12 months of Tier 1 probation, including a $250 fine and court costs, 50 community service hours, a 10-day vehicle immobilization and 3 months of interlock monitoring. If the same driver had blown 0.17, the program's Tier 2 would apply, while section 316.656(2)(a) would bar a judge from accepting a plea to a lesser offense, which is why the program uses the State's nolle prosequi instead. This is a hypothetical illustration of published terms, not a promise of admission or any result.

Common mistakes people make

• Assuming every first DUI gets reduced; the statute and the State Attorney decide, not the driver.
• Filing discovery demands or motions in Palm Beach County before deciding about the first-time program.
• Thinking reckless driving is a civil ticket; it is a criminal charge with its own penalties and 4 points. The difference is set out in reckless versus careless driving.
• Not finishing the DUI program after a reckless plea where alcohol contributed, which leads FLHSMV to cancel the license until it is done.
• Overlooking the separate refuse-to-sign count that the program sheet lists with an adjudication.

What to do this week

1. Find the breath or blood result and any crash report.
2. Gather your prior record, including any earlier diversion.
3. Note your arraignment date and courthouse; in Palm Beach County the program plea is entered there.
4. Handle the 10-day license deadline, which runs regardless of any plea talks.
5. Speak with a lawyer before filing anything in the criminal case.

The day-by-day list for the first week is in what to do in the first week after a Florida DUI arrest.

Frequently asked questions

Is reckless driving a criminal offense in Florida?

Yes. A first conviction carries up to 90 days in jail and a fine of $25 to $500 (s. 316.192(2)), and more if it causes damage, injury or serious bodily injury.

Can adjudication be withheld on reckless driving?

Section 316.656 bars withholding adjudication only for DUI, so it does not stop a withhold on reckless driving, and the Palm Beach program's plea is "adjudication withheld." Why that matters is explained on our withhold page.

Does a reduced charge help with my license?

It avoids the DUI revocation in section 322.28, but reckless driving adds 4 points (s. 322.27(3)(d)), and the administrative suspension from the arrest is a separate matter. How those points count toward a suspension is set out in the Florida points thresholds.

Is there a first-time DUI program in Broward?

The Broward State Attorney's published list of diversion programs does not include a DUI-specific program. Its other programs are described on our page about Broward County courts and programs.

Do I still need FR-44 insurance after a reckless plea?

The FR-44 rule in section 324.023 applies to a DUI conviction or plea; whether it applies after a reckless driving plea is covered on our FR-44 page.

Will a reckless plea show up on my driving record?

Points are recorded for a reckless driving conviction. The Palm Beach program sheet says that on successful completion of probation "you will not receive any points against your license."

How can Mr. Mead help?

Mr. Mead has defended DUI cases in South Florida for more than three decades. He reviews the stop, the testing and the paperwork, explains which doors the statute leaves open in your case, and gives you an honest assessment of where you stand. No outcome can be promised, and past results do not guarantee a similar result. For a confidential conversation about your DUI charge, call (561) 362-6677, 24 hours a day.

Request a Call Back